Atticus Haygood Henslee and Marcellus Johenning:
The Post-Verdict Affidavit Campaign, the Investigation of the Jurors, the Credibility of Their Accusers, Judge Leonard Strickland Roan’s Decision, and the Georgia Supreme Court’s Rejection of the Bias Claims
Revised Thursday, October 15, 2026
By Brian Nelson
Monday, August 25, 1913: The Defense Goes After the Jury
On Monday, August 25, 1913, twelve men found Leo M. Frank guilty of murdering thirteen-year-old Mary Phagan at the National Pencil Company in Atlanta. Judge Leonard Strickland Roan sentenced Frank to death on Tuesday, August 26. Frank’s lawyers immediately began the legal fight to overturn the conviction, and within weeks they were building another case, this time against two of the men who had helped convict him. They were Atticus Haygood Henslee, a thirty-six-year-old traveling salesman, and Marcellus Johenning, a forty-six-year-old industrial employee.
Continue Reading →











